I did some stand-up tonight at a local club.  Wednesday night's open mic night, see.  I did it three weeks ago with moderate success -- success enough to try it again. 
So I put together my set: stuff about Phoebe Cates and robots and sacks full of gnomes and a superhero named Monosyllabic Man.  I brought energy, I brought delivery, I brought giddy delight for all things odd.
To a room full of college kids.
I was dying up there; it was critical.  I was on, I was doing it, I was totally there.  But it wasn't working.  I finished my five minutes and I was done.
I didn't get the laughs, but the guy who talked about trying to pee when you're drunk and you have an erection?  Belly-laughs. 
"Your material is funny," one of the judges later told me.  "You just have to find a way to make these people comfortable with odd.  Emo Phillips did it; Judy Tenuta did it.  You just need to find a way to work it in."
On the one hand -- yes, it's infuriating.  Being totally outdone by "If I make the push to piss, you'd better believe shit's gonna be flyin' out the other end" is really annoying.  But on the other waldo...there's a time and place for weird, and Frat Night ain't it.